Ed Herman vs.
Scott Smith
Two full careers, measured against each man's own division and against each other — the tape, the read, and every number behind them.
The men, measured.
Frame, age, layoff and recent form — green marks the edge on each line.
What the numbers say.
Scouting notes, auto-generated — only stats deviating more than 25% from the division median make this list. No narratives, just deviations.
Who did they actually beat?
Full-career records re-graded by the tier of opposition — the same grading the Contender Series pick model uses. Records built on tier-4 competition are worth less than records built on killers.
Ed Herman
Full career not yet synced for Ed Herman — tier grading appears once their record documentation lands (refreshes weekly).
In the UFC: 6-8 against opponents who walked in above .500 · avg opponent walk-in record +0.8 wins over .500
Scott Smith
Full career not yet synced for Scott Smith — tier grading appears once their record documentation lands (refreshes weekly).
In the UFC: 0-0 against opponents who walked in above .500 · avg opponent walk-in record -1.2 wins over .500
The stand-up battle.
Career totals; norms are the medians of each man's own division.
Significant strikes — landed & absorbed
Where the fight happens (share of sig. strike attempts)
Ed Herman
Distance 65.0% (norm 79.4%) · Clinch 19.3% (norm 9.1%) · Ground 15.7% (norm 10.3%)
Scott Smith
Distance 76.9% (norm 79.4%) · Clinch 19.5% (norm 9.1%) · Ground 3.6% (norm 10.3%)
What they throw (share of sig. strike attempts by target)
Ed Herman
Head 78.2% (norm 78.0%) · Body 15.0% (norm 13.4%) · Legs 6.8% (norm 8.4%)
Scott Smith
Head 87.7% (norm 78.0%) · Body 3.6% (norm 13.4%) · Legs 8.7% (norm 8.4%)
Zone accuracy matrix Landed / attempted by zone
Green ≥ division median, red below. UFCStats tracks position and target as separate splits.
| Zone | Herman L/A | Acc | Middleweight med | Smith L/A | Acc | Middleweight med |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BY POSITION | ||||||
| At distance | 423 / 1134 | 37.3% | 40.5% | 45 / 150 | 30.0% | 40.5% |
| In the clinch | 237 / 336 | 70.5% | 70.3% | 17 / 38 | 44.7% | 70.3% |
| On the ground | 191 / 274 | 69.7% | 69.1% | 4 / 7 | too few to rate | 69.1% |
| BY TARGET | ||||||
| To the head | 536 / 1363 | 39.3% | 38.9% | 55 / 171 | 32.2% | 38.9% |
| To the body | 214 / 262 | 81.7% | 71.7% | 3 / 7 | too few to rate | 71.7% |
| To the legs | 101 / 119 | 84.9% | 83.3% | 8 / 17 | too few to rate | 83.3% |
Zones with fewer than 25 attempts are marked "too few to rate". Each fighter is measured against the median of leaderboard-eligible fighters in his own division (Middleweight: 174 fighters · Middleweight: 174 fighters).
What lands on them Opponents' accuracy against each man
Green ≤ division median — harder to hit than the typical man in his division.
| Zone | vs Herman L/A | Opp acc | Middleweight med | vs Smith L/A | Opp acc | Middleweight med |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BY POSITION | ||||||
| At distance | 612 / 1191 | 51.4% | 39.5% | 59 / 135 | 43.7% | 39.5% |
| In the clinch | 189 / 239 | 79.1% | 70.9% | 30 / 55 | 54.5% | 70.9% |
| On the ground | 150 / 222 | 67.6% | 69.0% | 27 / 43 | 62.8% | 69.0% |
| BY TARGET | ||||||
| To the head | 631 / 1266 | 49.8% | 37.9% | 73 / 180 | 40.6% | 37.9% |
| To the body | 172 / 222 | 77.5% | 71.3% | 15 / 20 | too few to rate | 71.3% |
| To the legs | 148 / 164 | 90.2% | 82.1% | 28 / 33 | 84.8% | 82.1% |
The ground war.
Takedowns, control and submissions — career totals with each man's per-minute rates against his division norm.
Bars compare the two men's rates (per-minute / per-15 figures), not raw totals — Herman has more cage time on record.